The potential perils of paper gold and silver ETF's

I've blogged on this topic several times, and it's worth revisiting.

http://dailyreckoning.com/golden-shell-games/

The gist of the article states that the GLD and SLV ETF's are good proxies for the spot price of their respective precious metals, but in the event of "failures to deliver" physical gold and silver, the prices between the ETF's (paper contracts) and the physical prices would decouple, as the physical shortage would cause the prices of the actual metals to soar, while the ETF prices would languish. The reason is the precious metals COMEX futures contracts and ETF's are not backed by allocated bullion. They are derivatives, much like mortgage-backed securities were derivatives of the actual mortgages themselves. Buyers of said derivatives lost everything when subprime home borrowers defaulted on their mortgages. Holders of COMEX precious metals futures contracts, and the GLD and SLV ETF's would be similarly exposed to counterparty risks.

So if you believe you can trade the fluctuations of gold and silver prices, then the GLD and SLV ETF's may be a cost-effective trading vehicle. But if you are looking to hedge against inflation, currency debasement, and/or financial crisis, owning physical gold and silver may be a safer play, despite hefty premiums.

See disclaimers in the side bar.

Disclosure: no position in GLD or SLV.